January 16, 2021
Giant Birthday Cookie!
*This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my disclosure for more details!*
A giant chocolate chip cookie perfect for birthdays! Who doesn’t want a giant birthday cookie?!
So it’s 2021 now… and I thought it was about time that I posted one of the most highly requested recipes EVER. A giant birthday cookie. I can’t honestly blame you all for wanting one… who doesn’t want a giant cookie for their birthday if they like cookies?!
This beauty of a recipe is very heavily based on my cookie bar recipes, such as my mini egg cookie bars, and my kinder bueno cookie bars. The base recipe is so good, and it works so well every time I didn’t want to mess with it to be honest!
This recipe is also inspired by my mini egg cookie cake, and my triple chocolate cookie cake. I use those as inspiration as the baking times when baking into a round tin can vary quite a bit in comparison to a square tin, and you know… birthday cake!
So, I decided as everyone asks for a Millie’s inspired giant cookie, that I would go down the idea of a plain/vanilla cookie base, with chocolate chips inside. This is just because it’s the best base to start with, and you can SO easily swap it about and customise it to what you prefer!
For the base recipe, you can use real butter or a baking spread, but I do recommend using the two types of sugars, and the correct two types of sugars. They are there for a reason! I use plain flour because you don’t want the raising agent from self raising flour.
I also use cornflour – this is because it creates SUCH A GOOD TEXTURE. Please do not just skip it. If you can’t access any cornflour/cornstarch, then use 25g more plain flour instead! Please also make sure to use bicarbonate of soda/baking soda… and not baking powder.
I used a mixture of white and milk chocolate chips, but you can use any. You can use chocolate chips, chunks of a chocolate bar, milk, plain or white… or flavour chocolate such as terry’s chocolate orange, or Lindt for example! You can also use themed chocolate such as Mini Eggs!
I recommend sticking to a maximum of 400g of added chocolate because as you can see from the photo… it’s pretty full. The smallest amount I would say is 200g, otherwise it may become a little dry without any chocolate in there! Also, more chocolate the better in my opinion.
I decided to bake this giant birthday cookie into an 8″/20cm round cake tin, because that is a standard cake size for me! It takes 25-30 minutes to bake – and you want to keep an eye on it. You wan’t the top of the cookie to look dry, but you also do not want the mixture to wobble too much as it may be raw still!
If you want a large but thinner cookie, you can use a 9″/23cm round cake tin, and bake for 20-25 minutes instead, and follow the same rules as above! It’s easier to line the tin so that you can easily get the cookie out of the tin after, without breaking it into pieces!
For the topping, I just made a simple vanilla buttercream (you don’t need much as it’s only a cookie!) – and you can colour it to any colour you like!! I then used some shopbought letters for the ‘happy birthday’ and sprinkled on some cute sprinkles from Iced Jems as always!
Giant Birthday Cookie!
Ingredients
Cookie Cake
- 275 g Plain Flour
- 1 tsp Bicarbonate of Soda
- 1/2 tsp Salt
- 1 tbsp Cornflour
- 115 g Unsalted Butter/Stork
- 55 g White Granulated Sugar
- 135 g Light Brown Soft Sugar
- 1 Medium/Large Egg
- 1 tsp Vanilla Extract
- 100-200 g Milk Chocolate Chips/Chunks
- 100-200 g White Chocolate Chips/Chunks
Buttercream
- 75 g Unsalted Butter (room temp)
- 150 g Icing Sugar
- 1/2 tsp Vanilla Extract
Decoration
- Sprinkles/Candles/letters/etc
Instructions
- Preheat your oven to 190c/170fan and line a 8"/20cm round tin with parchment paper, and leave to the side for now.
- Whisk/mix the plain flour, bicarbonate, salt and cornflour together so its evenly distributed – leave to the side.
- In a larger bowl, melt the butter. Add in the two sugars, and whisk for about 2 minutes so the sugar starts to dissolve and the mixture is smooth. Add in the egg and the vanilla, and whisk again briefly until smooth.
- Add in the dry Ingredients, and the chocolate chips (apart from a small handful) and mix with a spatula or a mixer until a thick cookie dough is formed.
- Press the mixture into the bottom of the tin and press in the handful of chocolate chips into the top for decoration.
- Bake the cookie in the oven for 25-30 minutes, until the top of the cookie looks ‘dry’ and it's not wobbling!
- Leave the cookie to cool for about 10 minutes, then leave to cool fully on a wire rack.
- Once the cookie has cooled, beat the unsalted butter for a minute or two to loosen and soften.
- Add the icing sugar and vanilla extract and beat again until smooth.
- Pipe around the edge of the cookie however you want, and add any to the middle if you want.
- I then used some shopbought edible happy birthday letters, and some sprinkles!
Notes
- This cookie will be best eaten on the day of baking or the day after, but will last 4-5 days.
- You can use any chocolate chip or chopped chocolate you want in the cookie - stick to a minimum of 200g, and a maximum of 400g.
- If baking into 9"/23cm tin for a thinner but larger cookie, bake for 20-25 minutes.
- If you can't access Cornflour - use 25g more flour, but the texture will change.
- You can make the cookie chocolate themed by using 200g plain flour, and 50g cocoa powder.
- I use this 8" cake tin, or this 9" cake tin.
- These are the edible letters I used!
- These are the sprinkles I used.
ENJOY!
Find my other Cookie & Cookie Bar Recipes on my Recipes Page!
You can find me on:
Instagram
Facebook
Pinterest
Twitter
Youtube
J x
© Jane’s Patisserie. All images & content are copyright protected. Do not use my images without prior permission. If you want to republish this recipe, please re-write the recipe in your own words and credit me, or link back to this post for the recipe.
Hi!! I’d really like to make this cookie but with ginger and white chocolate, how would you recommend to add ginger into the recipe?
TIA x
I would take a look at my gingerbread NYC cookies for inspo! x
Ive just made this and it smells absolutely unreal but im unsure if its cooked too quickly as the top looks cooked but inside still seems to be uncooked and the mixture is still very wet not sure what ive done wrong or if it will harden up? Anybody else had this happen to them? X
This sounds like it could be your oven, but it does also need to cool fully so its baked as if its fresh out the oven it will still be wet. x
Hi. Am planning to make for a birthday tomorrow in this extreme heat though can I put the finished cookie in the fridge? Or would you suggest doing cookie today leave somewhere cool and do butter cream tomorrow? Thanks
Id leave it at room temp so the cookie doesn’t dry out! x
Just finished making this for my friend’s birthday! Came out perfect I’m so happy with it, thanks so much for the recipe as there isn’t many on the internet. For those saying theirs sunk in the middle, I put mine in the fridge for about an hour before baking it and no sinkage to report. Also, I used much less chocolate (150g) broken into chunks not chips and a 10 inch tin using the above recipe as I didn’t want it so chunky cake thickness so I guess it’s personal preference, but it’s still looking gooooood. Wooopeeee 🙂
Hi Jane…
I used the 8 inch tin, followed the recipe and mine ended up double the size! Haha.
I have cut it in half and turned it into a cookie sandwich but any ideas what may have cause this? I bake a lot and I can’t see where it’s gone wrong! heehee.
Hey, the cookie does rise during baking – is that what you mean?
I used a 25cm tin and it was still thicker than I expected, that said it went down really well at a barbecue party. I imagine in an 8 inch tin it would be about the thickness of a sponge cake and pretty dense.
Hi Jane,
I absolutely love this recipe! Made it for my nieces and they loved it. However, moving forward I’d want to make it a bit thinner as I felt it was too thick – would I half the amount of ingredients and how long would I put this in the oven for?
Thank you
Hey, Ahh yayy this makes me so happy! Half would probably be way too little – there is notes on the post about baking it in a 9 inch tin instead which would make it thinner xx
Hi Jane, apologies if this question already been asked but if I wanted to add frozen biscoff spread in the middle would i still use Same quantity of chocolate as in recipe? Many thanks x
hi jane, how would i substitute white chocolate into your buttercream recipe for this cookie? planning on baking this for my birthday coming up x
Hiya, add in 75g melted white chocolate! Enjoy xx
Hi Jane
I want to make an eggfree giant cookie, can I follow your vegan recipe and make a giant cookie? I want to make a 7inch slightly thinner one.
Also I’ve noticed in this recipe you mentioned to leave out the baking powder. Do I do the same In the vegan one?
Thank you
Hi Jane
This looks amazing! If I wanted to make this following your vegan cookie recipe and use white granulated sugar and light brown sugar with soft butter would it work?
Would you suggest any other alterations? Also would I also bake that for 25-35 mins?
Thanks
Hiya, yes this would work bake for the same time as this recipe although it might be quite soft and a bit more cake like where its vegan xx
If I’m making a couple ahead, is it possible to freeze? Would I freeze the dough or the baked cookie? Thanks
I mean you can do either – but personally I would freeze the dough and bake from frozen x
Hello, will the recipe work without adding chocolate at all or would the recipe need tweaking??
Thank you
Hiya! It would it just may be a bit dry xx
I’ve made this before and it turned out really well, such a good recipe, so I’m making it again. I’ve accidentally added an additional 200g of choc chips (so 600g in total) will this ruin the cookie??
Hi what piping nozzle did you use please?
2d closed star!!
Hi Jane
When you say use 1.5 times the recipe for a 10 inch tin how would you do the egg(as you can’t really halve an egg)should I just use 2?
Use two small eggs, or a large one and a yolk x
Thankyou. My eggs are mixed sizes. What are the weights for different sized eggs?
Thankyou.
Hi,
Just wondered if this could be made using oreos? If so, would I be better off using oreo biscuits or the dairy milk blocks with oreos in?
Thanks 🙂
I would use the dairy milk so there is still some gooey to it otherwise it may be a bit dry – but some oreos added in won’t hurt!!
Hi, I love your recipes!
I want to try making cookie pizzas- could I use any of your cookie recipes and then bake them the same way as this recipe? Leave it to cool and then slice? Thanks!
Hey! Thank you so much, yes its worth a go xx
Hi Jane, if I wanted to make this in a 10 inch round tin, should I do 1.5 times the ingredients? Thanks
Hello! Yes this should work xx
Hi, how much more or world you keep the same mixture for a square 9” tin? Thank you!
Hey! I would keep it the same as that is the same as my cookie bar recipes xx
The taste and flavour is amazing!
Each time I’ve made it the cookie has sunk and/or cracked around the top edge? I read the messages on here and tried not fully melting the butter. Have you got any advice? I was going to maybe take out the bicarb? Would that help?
Hii! Its worth trying a bigger tin instead (such as the 9 inch mentioned on the post) as that may help prevent the cracking, the bicarb is important xx
Hi, would it be possible to make this into a double choc chip cookie?
Hello, there are detail on how to do this in the notes x
I love this recipe and have made it so many times now! I’ve had a friend ask if it can be made gluten, dairy and soya free?
I mean its easy to use a dairy free butter, and then gluten free flour – but soya depends on the other ingredients and the substitutes you are using!
I have a 12 inch round tin that I would like to try this recipe in, would it be ok if I reduce the cooking time and not make it as thick
I would say a 12″ is far too big for the same recipe – volume wise a 12″ is almost 2.3x the volume compared to an 8″ tin!
I use a 10 inch round tin and the size is perfect if you want a wider/thinner cookie like Miss Millies.
Hi Jane, will this work in an 8” square tin please?
Yes! The baking time is roughly the same but maybe a couple minutes less x
Hi Jane. Can’t wait to make this! Just wondering when you say any chocolate would work, does this include frozen rolos and other caramelly chocolates? Thanks
Anything soft centred I would freeze, but yes basically anything works!
Hi Jane, I have just made to cookie and can’t wait to dig in later. Mine sunk in the middle like other people have mentioned but I don’t mind to much ☺️ I do have a question though, I always find my buttercream really hard to pipe – do you have any advice on this? Do I just need a wider tip maybe?
Yeah it may be too small – its worth just having a practice one day on a random cake or watch some of my YouTube videos!!
Hi Jane, do you think magic stars and white chocolate buttons would work as an alternative to white and milk choc chips? I’m trying to think what would work other than ordinary choc chips but want to save mini eggs until Easter weekend 😃 any other ideas of chocolates you think would go well?
Yes it would work well!! And honestly any you like work haha!
Hi Jane I’m wanting to make this double layered like the millies cookies, might be a silly question but can I just split this recipe into two? And how long would you cook it for ?
It depends on the tin you use – I would personally say 2x 8″ tins is too thin, but would say for 2x 7″ it could be good!
Hi Jane, can the cookie dough be put in the fridge like your others before baking? I am wondering if I can make it the day before baking and would this alter the baking time? Thanks ☺️
It definitely can be put in the fridge first to bake later! It won’t really alter the time but add a minute maybe! x
How much would I increase the recipe by to make it in a 9″ tin but keeping the same depth of cookie as an 8″
I would use about 1/3 more, but use 1 large egg and a splash of milk if the dough is a little dry! x
Hi Jane, thank you for the recipe. I used light brown sugar as per recipe which had been delivered via a family bakers. Anyway when we were eating it my daughter and hubby were asking what spices I’d put in, I hadn’t put any spices in whatsoever but they’re right, after a second tasting it was definitely spicey. In your opinion do you think it was their light brown sugar and is that normal for it to taste like that when baked do you think? Intrigued. Thanks x
That shouldn’t be the sugar – it has a more natural caramel flavour but I wouldn’t say enough to say spicy! X
Hi,
if I wanted to make this a double chocolate cookie – would I swap out 15g of flour and replace with cocoa powder?
I would do 25g cocoa powder, replacing 50g flour!
Hi, by how much would I need to increase the recipe to use a 9″ tin but keeping the same depth of cookie as the 8″ tin?
You would need to use about 1/3 more – use a large egg maybe and a yolk and add a splash of milk to bind the cookie dough enough x
Hi Jane, Absolutely love your recipes have made loads of them. I tried this cookie for valentines and it really sunk and broke apart so I tried it again today and cooked it for much longer than 30 mins and it’s still sunk upon cooling. Help?
Ohh no! So I had to google, but it may be worth using softened butter instead of melted and see if that helps you? x
Could this be made vegan? Thanks!
Yes! Look on my vegan cookie recipe for inspiration! X
Hi Jane, I wanted to use a 9” tin but keep the depth of the cookie. I used a conversion chart I found online and it said to increase the ingredients by 1/4, I did this but think it was too much bicarbonate as it Was like a cake and really didn’t taste nice at all. Could you tell me how much I should have increased the quants by.
Thank you
Sometimes raising agents are as easily multiplied – it may be worth keeping that is to be honest and hopefully it will taste better!
I absolutely love your recipes and they always turn out really well with everyone enjoying them, thank you! However this is the first fail. My oven is the right temperature, I followed everything but when I checked at 25 mins thought a bit of a wobble like you mentioned so left it a few mins but it still didn’t seem ready, it looked more cakey than Cookie? Anyhow I covered with foil a little longer then left if with the foil to fully cool. However when I went to remove it, it looked a bit sunken like a cake does? The only thing I didn’t have cornflour so used the plain flour like you said. Any ideas what could have happened so I can have another go? Thanks! x
This is so strange! It may be worth making the butter slightly softened compared to melted and see if that helps you – it can be because its under baked, but mine slink ever so slightly which is natural, but it shouldn’t completely sink in the middle! x
Thanks Jane, no it only sunk a bit but after reading the other comments where theirs had sunk too I don’t feel too bad. I think next time I’ll turn the oven down a bit as mentioned in another comment and cook it for longer
I made this giant cookie for my son’s birthday tomorrow, beautifully baked. However after cooling the middle of the cookie had sunk leaving a dip.😞
That can mean its slightly under baked – but buttercream can hide that! x
Hi Jane
If I was to make this with mini eggs to make it Easter themed, How many grams of the mini eggs would you recommend I use?
300g!! x
Can I use caster sugar or golden caster sugar instead of granulated sugar as I find granulated sugar in cookies can be a bit too sweet.
I want to make this cookie but I have ran out of plain flour. If I change to self raising, will the texture be awful? I only have about 50g of plain left.
Could I swap but not use any bicarbonate of soda or will this still not work?
Thanks in advance.
Because its only 50g it should be fine – I just wouldn’t recommend self raising flour for all of it!
It’ll only be 50g of plain so 185g self raising. However, I assume that won’t work after reading your original reply?
Oh sorry I misunderstood – that may cause it to rise and have a bit of a cakey texture yes!
No problem, thank you!!
Made this today for my fiancé for Valentine’s Day – absolutely amazing! 🍪
Made this giant cookie today for my hubby for Valentine’s Day – absolutely delicious and so easy! Thank you Jane for another great recipe.
Hi, if I was making 2 giant cookies in the oven at the same time (8inch size), how much longer would they need to bake for? Thanks!
If you are using two separate tins the timings would be the same.
Hey 😁! Just wandering, would i be able to make this into a cookie pie with nutella inside please? Do you know if i would need to adjust the recipe at all? Thank you in advance 😊 x
Hi Jane! Can’t wait to try this. Just wondering, could I prep this the day before, leave the cookie dough in the tin in the fridge and then just bake like normal the next day? Or even 2 days? Thank you! Xx
I’d recommend only a day if you can help it, but raw dough can do up to 48 hours in the fridge. But generally if any longer than a day I will freeze the dough x
Hello, I have today tried to bake your giant cookie, however I have just cut into it and seems to be raw in the middle, what is the texture supposed to be like? I cooked for 30 mins 170 fan and the top was dry looking and crispy on top and no wobble. Is there a way I could recook tomorrow to get the middle more cooked ? Thank you.
Oh no! That definitely doesn’t sound good. Are you definitely sure the oven is the correct temp? And did you use the correct type of butter etc? You wouldn’t be able to bake the same cookie again unfortunately (but also if you did cut into the cookie when still warm it will look raw still as it needs to cool fully!) X
Hi Jane
I love all your recipes and have made this before! I am just wondering what difference it makes if I use Stork against butter? What would you recommend using out of the two?
You can use either xx
Hello Jane, just wondering if you could help. I’ve read all the post, notes and comments before writing to you. How much more time than 30 mins would you recommend? It’s just my cookie has come out raw in the middle and it was in for 30 mins. Or do you think i should put my fan oven down to 160 maybe next time for 30 mins? Not really sure where I’ve gone wrong. X
Did you cut into the cookie before it had cooled? It needs to cool fully as it will continue to bake whilst cooling, but it may be the oven wasn’t at the correct temp! x
Hi,
When you say press down do you mean flat into the tin?
Yep, you have to fill the tin to the edges so the mixture is flat x
ade these before and they’re so amazing!! I’m making these into a stack with buttercream like a cake.
Would I be able to use light brown muscavado instead of light brown soft sugar? Thanks
Yes you can use muscovado! Just make sure to beat it properly so it doesn’t leave a grainy texture as sometimes the grains are bigger!
I made this today and put if in an 8 inch tin but it was too thick and burnt on the outside and was not fully cooked inside. What did I do wrong?
That sounds like your oven was too hot!! The cookie is thick though (notes on using a 9″ tin to get it thinner if thats what you are after) but to burn and be raw means the oven temp is wrong x
Hi Jane
This recipe is amazing I’ve made it so many time already. How would I adjust the recipe I I was to make it in a 7inch foil tin
If we were storing the cookie dough in the fridge or freezer before baking, do we need to bring it to room temperature before using or adjust the bake time? Thanks.
Fridge, no – freezer, just add 1-2 minutes baking time x
Can’t wait to make this – just wondering if you
Could you serve this warm with ice cream ?
Yes definitely! Warm cookie and ice cream is the best x
Hi Jane!
Made this for my boyfriends birthday using kinder pieces and went down great!
I have one question, I lined my round baking tin fully (cut the sheet to size) using an Asda £3.50 round tin and found it cooked a lot round the sides meaning it went hard, is this normal or could you provide any tips?
Thanks so much, love all your recipes!
It may be the tin is quite thin or transfers heat different – but the outside edge will naturally be harder! x
Looking forward to making this instead of a cake for 11 yo Grand daughters birthday at the weekend.
Hi Jane, how I adjust this recipe to make it thinner. I attempted it in a 23cm tin yesterday and it turned out great but was a little thick. Thank you x
You’d have to use an even bigger tin if you wanted it thinner such as a 10″ x
Hi Jane,
This recipe looks amazing, I can’t wait to make it next weekend for a lockdown birthday treat for a friend! Could you use some dairy milk caramel chocolate in the cookie?
Thank you in advance 😊
Yes you can! But I would freeze the caramel filled chocolate first xx
Hi Jane, just wondering how i could adapt this to make it a six inch?
It depends on what depth you want but I usually say 2/3 of the recipe for a 6″ – and you’d just have to use as small an egg as you can find!
Love this recipe! If I wanted to make dairy free would you recommend stork baking block?
Yes! x
Hi Jane. My oven runs slightly hot so I cooked at 160 instead and cooked it for 30mins and found the edges cooked too much.
Would you say that timing on 160 is ok? Can you cover with foil to stop the top cooking too quickly?
Hello! The edges will always bake more than the middle but it may be worth covering with foil just incase x
Hi, can i use self raising instead of the plain flour and bicarb?
For this one plain flour is best x
I’m going to make this in silicone number moulds. One mould is 32x19x6cm, 1.6L and the other 32x26x6cm, 2.4L. Can you recommend how much mixture I would need?
I’m really not sure I am afraid sorry! Best to make double just in case and then just make cookies with spare if there is any!
Where’s the best place to store the finished cake, I put mine in the fridge?
Room temp! Never the fridge x
Hi Jane,
Is there anywhere you recommend buying edible lettering from?
thanks!
I’ve linked it on the post!
Can I make this into a heart shape?
Yes you can use a heart shape tin!
Hi Jane, could i use cadbury choc buttons and milky bar choc buttons as i have looked at callebaut choc drops and they are a bit pricey ? Thanks x
Yes defo! x
Hi Jane, can this be made gluten free? X
Yes! Just use gluten free flour xx
Hi Jane.. going to make this yummy cookie is it ok to make up the mixture and keep in fridge overnight and bake the morning.
Yes you can!
Thanks for the recipe, it was a hit in our house and I will definitely make it again. I only battled a bit to get the chocolate chips properly mixed in the dough, but after some effort it was good enough 🙂
Could you add the method of melting dark chocolate and butter so the cookie is fudgey or will it not hold as much?
Honestly I’m not sure – I never melt chocolate for cookie dough x
Hi Jane,
If I put a spread in the middle like Nutella will it take longer to cook?
It could do yes depending no how much you use, but not by much – I would let the cookie cool in the tin though as you may struggle to get it out cleaning if its stuffed!
Hi Jane when you say melt butter can you put it in the microwave then put in a bowl with sugars ?
Yes!!
I made this amazing Giant Cookie for my husbands 72nd birthday. I was delighted with the results and so was he. I used all the chocolate and made the chocolate dough too. I used with buttercream frosting.
This was my first ever bake from Jane’s Patisserie and it won’t be the last. I’m hooked.
I live in south west France so I have lots of inspiration but this website is the best.
Thank you Jane.
Hi Jane,
This looks amazing, how much extra would I need to do a 10 inch cookie? Xx
I would use about another half of the recipe! Not sure on the baking time but it would be more!! x
Thank you x I added a 1/4 more and is amazing!!! Just done another one with the normal recipe and a 10 inch and still a nice depth!!! Amazing cookie!!! X think I need to cook a bit longer as the middle sunk a bit x love your recipes x
Hi jane, to make this vegan, could i substitute the egg for almond milk or would flax seed be better?
For this I would do the flaxseed personally, but either works!
Hi, made this today it’s just cooling and smells lovely! However it has sunk a bit in the middle any tips to prevent this next time? x
I usually find it happens when it’s slightly under baked, but it can naturally happen ever so slightly anyway! x
Hi Jane,
Would the method change at all with your Red Velvet cookie recipe? I’m going to make this for my son’s 18th next week 😃 so happy you posted a giant cookie recipe!
You can stick to the recipe of the red velvet, but using the cooking temps/timings/tin etc of this one!
Just made this for my son’s birthday. Did the decorations in claret & blue (Aston Villa). He was delighted with it.
Thanks for sharing, this cookie looks an amazing treat for a birthday 🙂
Hiya Jane, really want to try this recipe out but with a thicker filling (clever cookie style). Would this mean I will need to make more dough and if so what would you recommend I do? Thank you so much
Loved it !! I was wondering could I also make their recipe with peanut m&ms ??? Would it be any different x
That would work!
Hi Jane- do you think you could freeze the cookie once it’s cooked? Or would it be better to freeze the dough instead?
Either is fine, but I personally find freezing the raw dough better!
My baby is going to be 18 in February and he just loves cookies, so this is going to be his birthday cake, can’t wait to try it, just loving your website and recipes……thank you x
Waw. I made this 2 nights ago. It was out of this world. Absolutely delicious. I follow a lot of your recipes as I love to bake for fun. Thank you so much.
Hello Jane, I am making this on Friday for my boyfriends birthday. This may be a silly question so apologies in advance, when you line the cake tin, do you just line the bottom or the edges as well? I’m new to baking and want to make sure I get this right. Thank you x
I usually just line the bottom, but you can line the sides as well just in case it sticks x
Hi Jane I was going to make this for my sisters bday and was just wondering what tray or dish you put the cookie in 🙂
Looks delicious btw
The one I used is linked on the post!
Hi!
If I wanted to make this a triple choc cookie how much coco powder should I use?
Thanks! x
Mentioned on the post!
Hey Jane! I know you have in your recipe to use the sugars directly indicated in the recipe, but I only have dark brown sugar and white granulated sugar. Do you think the end result would be the same? Or would I have to modify it a bit? Or should I simply just get the light brown sugar? Thank you!!! So excited to try the recipe!
Hey! So you can definitely still use those as they are similar enough, but I would use 50/50 to balance it a little more flavour wise xx
Would love to make this heart shaped for valentine’s, but don’t have a heart tin, do you think it would spread too much if I just shaped it and put it on a baking sheet ??
Unfortunately it can spread a bit as it’s a cookie mixture, so it may be best to try and make a foil edge in the shape you want if that makes sense x
Would I be able to use something like Reese’s pieces instead of one of the chocolates?
Yes!
Hi Jane can this be made gluten free
Yes – using gluten free ingredients should work well x
Hi Jane, if I wanted to make this egg free, what could I use as a substitute? Xx
Could I please ask how your cookie turned out using gluten free flour? I have just tried and the end result isn’t great. The side have risen a lot and the top is very crumbly. Any tips would be welcome.
I made this today but made it a double chocolate flavour by adding coco powder. It was delicious, tastes very cookieish.
Do you know how many Claire is there are in each slice?
Looks amazing
What icing tip did you use to create the pattern you did with the buttercream?
Can’t wait to try
2d closed star! x
Wow wow wow!! Tried this as soon as you posted, couldn’t resist. So glad I did, so much better than Millies cookies! Would this work with chopped up chocolate orange or dairy milk? X
Yesss it would work well with either!
Hi Jane, I would really like to try this recipe today but I only have a 6″ tin. How can I adapt the recipe? 😀
I would use 2/3 of the recipe roughly and use as small an egg as you can. Baking time will be maybe 20 minutes or so?
You must have read my mind Jane as I was only thinking about looking for a recipe for a giant cookie! I’ve been making your NYC cookies and the white and raspberry cookies- a massive hit!! Thank you for this recipe!!
Paula how are you perfecting the white raspberry cookies because mine had green on me I can’t perfect it and I’m losing my mind 🙂
Hi Jenna- we still get a bit of green as well but we just ignore it😊 They still taste lovely!
If I wanted to make this vegan what is the best ingredient and ratio for egg replacer please?
Thanks
Jenny
I would use any egg replacer recommended on google as there are so many different ways x
Thank you. I am Going use flaxseed. What quantity would you suggest please?
For one egg I usually use 1tbsp flaxseed with 3tbsp water x
This looks great, I’m going to make it in a couple of weeks for my lockdown birthday. What chocolate chips do you use please, the ones from the supermarket I find are usually small and hard, even when cooked! Thanks
I use Callebaut!
Hi jane great recipe! Making this today 😁 how would I up this to a 12 inch cookie with the same level of thickness?
Thank you
Oh gosh – you would need to at least double it (volume wise you use 2.3x the recipe) Baking time might mean the outside is rather done before the inside unless you lower the temp and bake for a lot longer x
Hello
I want to make this gorgeous looking giant cookie 2 days in advance. Is it possible and how should I store it please?
As mentioned on the post its ideally eaten day of baking or day after, but can last 4-5 days. So I would store it in a plastic container at room temp x
Hi Jane. Love all your recipes especially the cookie recipes and Bakewell cheesecake. I’ve baked a few cookie cakes using your recipes but occasionally they sink in the middle. What could be doing wrong here? Thank you 🙂
That often means to me that they are under baked!
I have been using your cookie bar recipe to make family and friends giant cookies for a while now! It’s absolutely delicious and perfect for a special occasion.
You’ve gone and done it again! Absolutely incredible. I can’t wait to try this out – kinder springs to mind
🌰🍪🤎